Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. and legal logic / Frederic R. Kellogg.
2018
KF8745.H6 K449 2018 (Mapit)
Available at Stacks
Items
Details
Title
Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. and legal logic / Frederic R. Kellogg.
Imprint
Chicago : The University of Chicago Press, 2018.
Copyright
©2018.
Description
229 pages ; 24 cm
Formatted Contents Note
The law lectures
Prologue
Logic
Science
Induction
Realism
Dispute and adjustment
Principles
Positivism
Logical theory
Validation.
Prologue
Logic
Science
Induction
Realism
Dispute and adjustment
Principles
Positivism
Logical theory
Validation.
Summary
"[In this book], Frederic R. Kellogg examines the early diaries, reading, and writings of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. (1841-1935) to assess his contribution to both legal logic and general logical theory. Through discussions with his mentor Chauncey Wright and others, Holmes derived his theory from Francis Bacon's empiricism, influenced by recent English debates over logic and scientific method, and Holmes's critical response to John Stuart Mill's 1843 A System of Logic. Conventional legal logic tends to focus on the role of judges in deciding cases. Holmes recognized input from outside the law--the importance of the social dimension of legal and logical induction: how opposing views of "many minds" may converge. Drawing on analogies from the natural sciences, Holmes came to understand law as an extended process of inquiry into recurring problems. Rather than vagueness or contradiction in the meaning or application of rules, Holmes focused on the relation of novel or unanticipated facts to an underlying and emergent social problem. Where the meaning and extension of legal terms are disputed by opposing views and practices, it is not strictly a legal uncertainty, and it is a mistake to expect that judges alone can immediately resolve the larger issue." -- Publisher's website.
Bibliography, etc. Note
Includes bibliographical references and index.
Location
STA
Call Number
KF8745.H6 K449 2018
Language
English
ISBN
9780226523903 hardcover ; alkaline paper
022652390X hardcover ; alkaline paper
9780226524061 electronic book
022652390X hardcover ; alkaline paper
9780226524061 electronic book
Record Appears in